Sourdough Pesto Grilled Cheese

The rain was drumming against my kitchen window last Tuesday when I remembered half a jar of pesto languishing in the fridge. Something about gray weather makes me crave that specific combination of warm bread and melted cheese, but I wanted to elevate it beyond my usual routine. The three-cheese blend was an experiment born from cleaning out my cheese drawer, and honestly, it's become my new standard.

My roommate walked in mid-sizzle and immediately abandoned her plans to make a salad. Theres something profoundly comforting about the sound of butter hitting hot bread, the way it fills the whole apartment with promises of dinner. We ate them standing at the counter, napkins inadequate for the job, trading bites and agreeing this was the best version of grilled cheese either of us had ever made.

Ingredients

• Thick-cut sourdough bread: The sturdy texture holds up beautifully to three kinds of cheese without getting soggy, and those air pockets create irresistible crispy edges
• Shredded mozzarella cheese: Provides that classic cheese pull and mild base that lets the other flavors shine
• Shredded fontina cheese: This is my secret weapon for exceptional grilled cheese, it melts into the creamiest, most luxurious texture
• Shredded sharp white cheddar: Adds the necessary punch and tang to balance out the richness
• Basil pesto: Spread it on the inside of the bread so the herbs toast slightly and release their oils
• Unsalted butter: Softened butter spreads more evenly than cold, ensuring every inch of bread gets perfectly golden

Instructions

Prep your bread:

Butter one side of each sourdough slice with half a tablespoon of softened butter, then flip them over and spread a generous tablespoon of pesto on the unbuttered side of just two slices

Layer the cheeses:

Pile an even mix of mozzarella, fontina, and cheddar onto the pesto-covered slices, right to the edges so the cheese gets crispy and lacy

Assemble the sandwiches:

Top each cheesy slice with the remaining bread, buttered side facing out, pressing down gently to help everything stick together

Get that perfect sear:

Cook in a hot skillet over medium heat for about 4 minutes per side, pressing gently with your spatula, until golden brown and the cheese is completely melted

The patience step:

Let the sandwiches rest for one full minute before slicing, which gives the cheese a moment to set so it doesn't all ooze out when you cut

Save to Pinterest

My mother-in-law asked for the recipe after one bite at our last family dinner, claiming she'd never tasted a grilled cheese with such depth. Watching people's eyes light up when that first pull of cheese happens, it reminds me why I bother with the extra effort of multiple cheeses and careful layering. Food this simple shouldn't make people this happy.

Choosing Your Pesto

Homemade pesto is wonderful, but don't stress about making it from scratch. I've found that a good quality store-bought version works perfectly here, especially since it's getting heated and melded with cheese. If you do make your own, go light on the garlic since it will intensify when toasted.

The Cheese Strategy

The three-cheese combination isn't just for show, each one plays a specific role. Mozzarella gives you that classic cheese pull, fontina adds incredible creaminess, and sharp cheddar provides the flavor backbone. I learned the hard way that skipping any one of them makes the sandwich feel incomplete.

Make It Your Own

Once you've mastered the basic technique, this sandwich becomes a canvas for whatever you're craving. I've added everything from caramelized onions to roasted red peppers, and each variation brings something new to the table.

• A few thin tomato slices add freshness and prevent the sandwich from feeling too heavy
• Baby spinach or arugula wilts slightly and adds a nice contrast to all that richness
• A smear of garlic butter on the outside instead of plain butter takes it over the top

Save to Pinterest

There's nothing quite like cutting into a perfectly grilled sandwich and watching steam escape with that incredible pesto aroma. Make one for yourself, then make another because you'll definitely want seconds.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ Can I use different cheeses for this sandwich?

Absolutely. While the recipe calls for mozzarella, fontina, and sharp cheddar, you can substitute with Gruyère, provolone, or any melting cheese you prefer. Experiment to find your favorite combination.

→ How do I prevent the bread from burning while the cheese melts?

Cook over medium heat rather than high heat, and use a nonstick skillet. Press gently with a spatula and monitor the bread closely. If browning too quickly, lower the heat slightly and allow more time for the cheese to melt.

→ What are some filling variations?

Try adding thin tomato slices, baby spinach, caramelized onions, or roasted red peppers between the cheese layers. These additions complement the pesto beautifully without complicating the preparation.

→ Is there a dairy-free option?

Yes. Use plant-based butter, dairy-free cheese alternatives, and nut-free pesto to create a fully vegan version. The cooking method remains the same, though dairy-free cheeses may melt differently.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

Assemble the sandwiches up to 2 hours in advance and refrigerate. When ready to cook, add 1-2 extra minutes per side since the filling will be cold. Alternatively, prepare the pesto and cheese mixture the day before.

→ What's the best bread to use if I don't have sourdough?

Thick-cut brioche, challah, or Italian bread work well as substitutes. Sourdough adds a tangy flavor, but any sturdy bread that can withstand grilling without falling apart is suitable.