Santa's Beard Hat Board

I'll never forget the year my neighbor challenged me to create something festive that would steal the show at our holiday potluck. I was standing in my kitchen on a gray December afternoon, surrounded by an array of cheeses and cured meats, when it hit me—why not make Santa himself the centerpiece? That first Santa Beard and Hat Board was born from pure creativity and a little bit of holiday magic, and it's become the one thing guests ask me to bring every single year since.

I still remember my cousin's kids discovering this board at our family dinner three years ago. Their faces lit up when they realized what they were looking at, and suddenly everyone was gathered around, not just eating but laughing and taking photos. It became the memory of that evening—not the turkey or the sides, but this whimsical creation that brought pure joy to the table.

Ingredients

• Brie cheese, sliced (200g): This creamy powerhouse is the foundation of Santa's fluffy beard—the way it melts on your tongue is what makes guests come back for more. I always chill it for 10 minutes before slicing so it holds its shape beautifully.
• Goat cheese, crumbled (200g): Its tangy bite adds complexity to the beard and creates little pockets of flavor that surprise you. The crumbles also catch the light and add visual texture.
• White cheddar, cubed (150g): This is your anchor cheese—it's sturdy enough to hold its shape all evening and has enough flavor to stand on its own when crackers aren't involved.
• Mozzarella balls, halved (150g): These little gems provide a creamy contrast and their mild flavor lets other ingredients shine. Halving them makes them easier to grab.
• Cream cheese, shaped into balls (100g, optional): If you want to get fancy, these add an extra layer of luxury and an almost cloud-like texture to the beard.
• Assorted white crackers (200g): Don't skimp here—quality crackers are your vehicle for the cheese. I mix rice crackers, water crackers, and herb varieties for textural interest.
• Genoa salami, sliced (150g): The deep burgundy color is essential for Santa's hat. Salami's rich, slightly spiced flavor is what makes the hat section sing.
• Prosciutto, rolled (100g): Its delicate saltiness and silky texture add elegance to the hat. Rolling it creates visual height and movement.
• Pepperoni slices (100g): The peppery bite and characteristic color deepen the red tone of the hat. These are what make people reach for more.
• Roasted red bell peppers, sliced (2 large): Their sweetness balances the saltiness of the meats and their natural shine makes the hat look glossy and vibrant. I use jarred ones to save time.
• Cherry tomatoes or mini red peppers (1 cup): These are your garnish that doubles as flavor—they add freshness and prevent the board from feeling too heavy.
• Fresh rosemary sprigs: Beyond just decoration, their piney aroma makes people hungry before they even taste anything. Break them gently to release their oils.
• Black olive (1): This single olive becomes Santa's pom-pom and ties the whole concept together in the most delightful way.

Instructions

Map Out Your Board:

Picture Santa's silhouette on your board. Lightly outline a triangle at the top for the hat using your finger or a toothpick in the cheese—you're essentially creating a map that will guide your assembly. Make the base rounded and generous, like Santa's jolly belly.

Build the Fluffy Beard:

This is where the magic happens. Start with your brie slices, laying them out like they're catching light from a candle. Scatter the crumbled goat cheese between them like snowdrifts. Then add cubes of white cheddar and the halved mozzarella balls, tucking cream cheese balls into the gaps. The goal is to create something that looks impossibly fluffy and soft—like you could sink your fingers right into it.

Create the Foundation:

Arrange your white crackers around the base and sides of the beard section. These aren't just support—they're the invitation to dig in. Arrange them in overlapping rows that suggest Santa's beard extends down onto the board itself.

Craft the Red Hat:

Now shift your focus to that triangle at the top. Layer your Genoa salami in overlapping concentric circles, like you're painting with cured meat. The overlaps create depth and richness. Weave in the rolled prosciutto and pepperoni slices, alternating for visual interest. The goal is a hat so red it practically glows.

Add Pepper Brightness:

Arrange those roasted red pepper strips in waves throughout the hat, adding curves and movement. They soften the sharp lines and add a sweet note that the meats alone can't provide.

Crown with Jewels:

Scatter your cherry tomatoes or mini red peppers around the tip and along the hat's edge. These bright pops of color make the whole board look alive and fresh.

Garnish Festively:

Use fresh rosemary sprigs to create a decorative outline between the hat and beard, like you're framing Santa's face. These green accents are the finishing touch that makes it unmistakably festive.

Add the Final Flourish:

Place that single black olive at the very tip of the hat, and suddenly it's not just a board—it's Santa. Step back and admire your creation. You've just built edible art.

Serve with Pride:

Bring it to the table immediately while everything is fresh and cool. Have small cheese knives nearby and let people graze freely. Replenish the crackers and any sparse spots as the evening progresses, but the board will only get more charming as it's enjoyed.

Save to Pinterest

What I treasure most about this board is how it transforms a simple appetizer into a moment of pure delight. It's become the thing that makes people pause, smile, and feel like childhood again—all from something that's really just cheese and meat arranged with intention and a little bit of imagination.

Customizing Your Board

The beauty of this concept is that it's incredibly flexible. If you're feeding vegetarians, simply omit all the cured meats and double down on roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, and use red-hued cheeses like Red Leicester or aged gouda for the hat section. You could even use sliced beets for an unexpected pop of color. For the beard, you have endless options—smoked gouda, camembert, ricotta salata—whatever calls to you. The important thing is maintaining that contrast between white and red, so Santa is unmistakably recognizable.

Pairing and Presentation

Serve this alongside a crisp sparkling wine or festive cranberry spritzers—the acidity cuts through the richness of the cheese and meats beautifully. I've found that guests appreciate having something to drink nearby, as the saltiness of the cured meats makes people thirsty. Set small cheese knives nearby and perhaps a small plate stack so people don't feel self-conscious about taking pieces. The more you treat it like a proper board rather than a casserole, the more people will engage with it respectfully.

Make-Ahead Magic and Storage

While the final assembly should happen close to serving time, you can absolutely prep your components ahead. Cube your cheeses, slice your meats, and arrange your peppers the morning of your event—just keep everything in separate containers in the fridge. This way, assembly becomes a 15-minute breeze instead of a last-minute scramble. On the rare occasion that you have leftovers, the cheeses and meats keep beautifully in sealed containers for 2-3 days, though I'll be honest—I've never had leftovers because people can't resist going back for 'one more piece of Santa's beard.'

Save to Pinterest

This board has taught me that the most memorable appetizers aren't necessarily complicated—they're the ones that spark joy and conversation. Every time you assemble it, you're not just making food; you're creating a moment that people will talk about long after the party ends.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ What cheeses work best for the beard section?

Soft and creamy cheeses like brie, goat cheese, white cheddar, mozzarella balls, and cream cheese offer a fluffy texture and mild flavors ideal for mimicking Santa's beard.

→ How can I make the hat vegetarian?

Omit the meats and use roasted red peppers, sundried tomatoes, and red-hued cheeses like Red Leicester to create a vibrant, meat-free hat design.

→ What are good drink pairings for this board?

Light sparkling wines and cranberry spritzers complement the mix of creamy cheeses and cured meats without overpowering the flavors.

→ Can I prepare this board ahead of time?

Yes, assemble shortly before serving to maintain freshness, especially for the crackers and fresh garnishes, but cheeses and meats can be prepared a few hours in advance.

→ How do I arrange the elements to resemble Santa's beard and hat?

Outline a triangle at the top of the board for the hat, layering red meats and peppers, and fill the rounded bottom area with white cheeses and crackers for the beard, garnishing with rosemary and a black olive pom-pom.